Test-Driven Development (TDD): Build Quality Software

By Abhay Talreja

5/11/2024

My latest article - What is Exploratory Testing? Learn with a real world example

Test-Driven Development (TDD) is an Agile-based software development (opens in a new tab) practice that prioritizes the creation of unit test cases before the development of the actual code.

Based on principles of the Agile Manifesto (opens in a new tab) and Extreme programming, (opens in a new tab) TDD enhances the delivery of high-quality software at high speed.

This approach is characterized by a unique cycle: writing failing tests first, followed by developing code to pass these tests, and then refactoring the code.

It offers rapid feedback to developers, enabling them to promptly identify and rectify issues, thereby streamlining the development process.

With its adaptability across various programming languages and its different forms, such as Acceptance TDD (ATDD) and Development TDD (DTDD), TDD has become a versatile and indispensable tool in the developer's arsenal.

Beyond its technical benefits, TDD is lauded for reducing bugs, enhancing code maintainability, and accelerating the pace of development, making it a cornerstone practice in the pursuit of high-quality software development.

What is Test Driven Development (TDD)?

Test Driven Development (TDD) is a software development practice that emphasizes the creation of unit test cases before writing the actual code. This approach aligns with the principles of Agile development and is recognized for its efficiency in delivering high-quality software.

TDD is an iterative approach involving programming, unit test creation, and refactoring. Developers create small test cases for every feature based on their understanding.

The core intention here is to modify or write new code only if the tests fail.

This methodology seeks to prevent the duplication of test scripts and produce optimized code that remains resilient in the long term.

To grasp the essence of TDD, let's first understand how it differs from the traditional software development approach.

Table 1: Comparing Traditional Development and Test-Driven Development

In essence, with TDD, you write tests before writing the code itself. This approach offers several advantages and changes the way you develop software.

TDD vs. Traditional Testing: Key Differences

The table below summarizes the primary distinctions between Test Driven Development and traditional testing methodologies:

Table 2: TDD vs. Traditional Testing: Key Differences

While TDD promotes a disciplined, specification-first approach that can lead to higher quality code and better-architected systems, traditional testing methods provide a comprehensive evaluation of the system after the development phase.

This makes traditional testing especially suitable for larger projects where different aspects of the system are tightly interconnected, and changes in one area might impact several others.

Test Driven Development (TDD) Simple Examples

Calculator Function

Consider the development of a calculator function. In TDD, you start by writing a test case for the "add" function, followed by the code necessary to make that test pass.

This iterative process continues for other functions such as "subtract," "multiply," and "divide."

E-commerce Website

Developing an e-commerce website using TDD entails crafting test cases for various features, including product listings, shopping cart functionality, and the checkout process.

These tests ensure the system functions correctly, from adding items to cart to completing the purchase.

The Three Phases of Test Driven Development

1. Create Precise Tests: Developers must craft precise unit tests that validate specific features. These tests should compile but usually fail initially, based on initial assumptions.

2. Correct the Code: After a test fails, developers make minimal code changes to ensure it passes when re-executed.

3. Refactor the Code: Once a test passes, developers review the code for redundancy and optimization opportunities without altering external behavior.

The Two Main Approaches to TDD

Primarily, TDD takes up one of two approaches: Inside Out or Outside In.

Inside Out Approach

In the Inside Out approach, the focus lies on the results or state.

Testing starts from the smallest unit level, and the architecture grows organically.

This typically involves minimal mocking and presents a way to prevent over-engineering.

The design happens during the refactor stage.

Outside In Approach

Conversely, the Outside In approach emphasizes user behavior.

Testing commences at the outermost level and moves inward with the evolving details.

This method heavily relies on mocking and stubbing external dependencies and aligns the code with the primary business needs.

The design occurs during the red stage.

Choosing the Appropriate Approach

The choice between these approaches relies on the specific situation.

Complex applications with numerous rapidly changing external dependencies, such as microservices, often align with the Outside In approach.

Conversely, smaller, monolithic applications are better suited for the Inside Out approach.

The Outside In approach also tends to complement front-end applications given their proximity to the end-user.

Benefits of Test Driven Development (TDD)

1. Optimized Code: TDD promotes the creation of efficient and optimized code.
2. Clearer Requirements: Developers gain a better understanding of client requirements.
3. Ease of Adding Functionality: Adding and testing new functionalities becomes more straightforward.
4. Comprehensive Test Coverage: TDD ensures high test coverage from the project's outset.
5. Improved Productivity: Developers become more productive, leading to flexible and maintainable code.

Tools and Frameworks for Test Driven Development

Various frameworks support TDD in different programming languages:

• PyUnit (opens in a new tab) and DocTest (opens in a new tab): Popular unit testing frameworks for Python.
• JUnit (opens in a new tab): A widely used unit testing tool for Java.
• TestNG (opens in a new tab): Another Java testing framework overcoming some of JUnit's limitations.
• RSpec (opens in a new tab): A testing framework for Ruby projects.
• MochaJS (opens in a new tab): One of the most popular JavaScript testing frameworks since 2011.
• Jest (opens in a new tab): It is arguably the most popular JavaScript testing framework
• Jasmine (opens in a new tab): It is an open-source JavaScript testing framework that is capable of testing all types of JavaScript applications.
• Karma (opens in a new tab): A popular open-source productive testing environment (Test Runner).
• Puppeteer (opens in a new tab): A Node library that provides a high-level API.
• Cypress framework (opens in a new tab): It is a JavaScript-based end-to-end testing framework built on top of Mocha making asynchronous testing simple and convenient.
• Selenium (opens in a new tab) is an open-source automation testing suite that is widely used for the automation testing of web applications.

Best Practices for Test Driven Development (TDD)

Effective TDD practices include:

1. Clear Requirements: Begin with a clear understanding of feature requirements.
2. Atomic Tests: Write small, focused tests for specific functionality.
3. Simplest Test Case First: Start with the simplest failing test case.
4. Edge Cases: Include tests for boundary conditions and edge cases.
5. Regular Refactoring: After a test passes, refactor code without altering behavior.
6. Fast Feedback Loop: Ensure quick test suite execution for rapid feedback.
7. Automation: Automate tests for consistency and integration.
8. Red-Green-Refactor: Follow the core TDD cycle of writing failing tests, implementing code, and refactoring.
9. Comprehensive Test Suite: Balance unit, integration, and acceptance tests.
10. Continuous Testing: Integrate testing into development, enabling consistent testing.

Real-World Example: Implementing TDD in a Fitness Tracking App Development Using JavaScript

Project Overview

The development team at a tech startup is tasked with creating a new fitness tracking app.

The app's goal is to allow users to track their daily physical activities, such as steps taken, calories burned, and workout routines, as well as monitor their progress over time.

The app will also offer motivational features, like setting personal goals and receiving awards for achieving them.

Objective of Using TDD

The team decides to use Test Driven Development (TDD) to ensure that the app is robust, easy to maintain, and flexible enough to handle future feature additions.

Using TDD will help them validate the functionality at every step and avoid future bugs as new features are added.

Setting Up the TDD Environment

For this JavaScript project, the team chooses Jest, a popular testing framework that works well with applications developed with React, a library chosen for building the user interface.

Installing Jest:

npm install --save-dev jest

Configuring Jest:

They set up Jest in their `package.json`` to automate testing processes and ensure integration with their continuous integration (CI) pipeline.

TDD Cycle Implementation

The development of the fitness tracking app is broken down into several features, starting with user authentication.

1. Writing the First Test - User Authentication

• Test Case: Ensure that the user can log in with an email and password.
• Jest Test Script:

// auth.test.js
const auth = require('./auth')
 
test('User logs in using email and password', () => {
  const user = auth.login('user@example.com', 'password123')
  expect(user).toBe('Logged in successfully')
})

2. Red Phase

• Initially, the test will fail because the auth.login function does not exist yet.

3. Green Phase

• Creating Minimal Code to Pass the Test:

// auth.js
function login(email, password) {
  // A simple check for example purposes
  if (email === 'user@example.com' && password === 'password123') {
    return 'Logged in successfully'
  }
}
module.exports = { login }

4. Refactor Phase

After getting the green light from the test, the team refines the code to handle more complex scenarios like error handling, password encryption, and integration with their database.

Developing Further Features Using TDD

Each new feature, such as tracking steps, logging workouts, and setting goals, undergoes the same TDD cycle.

The team writes tests first to define how the features should work, then writes the code to fulfill those tests, and finally refactors to optimize performance and maintainability.

Challenges and Adaptations

• Integrating External APIs: For features like syncing with external fitness devices, mocking external APIs in tests was crucial to ensure the internal logic was sound without relying on external services during testing.
• UI Testing: For the React components, the team used Jest alongside Enzyme, a tool for rendering component outputs, to test the user interface without launching a browser.

Project Outcome

The fitness tracking app was successfully developed and launched with high stability and minimal bugs at release.

The TDD approach significantly reduced the number of bugs found in production and improved the team's confidence in adding new features.

Conclusion

As development cycles become shorter and the demand for quality increases, TDD is set to become even more integral to software development processes.

It promotes a disciplined approach to coding and testing that aligns well with future technological advancements and methodologies.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) / People Also Ask (PAA)